What is normal wear and tear in a rental?

Normal wear and tear includes minor scuffs, small nail holes, carpet traffic patterns, and paint fading that occur from ordinary use. Per HUD Handbook 4350.1, paint has a 3-year useful life and carpet has a 5-year useful life. Landlords cannot charge tenants for depreciation beyond these periods.

Can my landlord keep my deposit for painting?

If you lived in the unit for more than 3 years, the paint has exceeded its useful life per HUD guidelines and cannot be charged to you. Even for shorter tenancies, landlords can only charge the depreciated value, not full repainting costs.

How do I fight unfair security deposit deductions?

Start by requesting an itemized list of deductions in writing. Compare each charge against HUD useful life guidelines (3 years for paint, 5 years for carpet). Document the condition with photos. Send a demand letter citing specific violations, then file in small claims court if ignored.

What is the HUD useful life guideline?

HUD Handbook 4350.1 establishes standard useful life periods for rental property items: interior paint (3 years), carpet (5 years), appliances (10-15 years per IRS Publication 527). Items beyond their useful life cannot be charged to tenants regardless of condition.

Deposit Forensics

Upload Landlord's Deduction Letter

Free — no credit card required

Targeted Defense

Reviewed by

Shield Apps Legal Research Team

Statutory Compliance Analysts

Scan Your Landlord's Letter for Illegal Deductions.
We'll Build the Response.

Did they miss the deadline? Did they fail to itemize? Our AI checks for procedural defects that void their claim instantly.

Charge Extraction → HUD / IRS useful-life lookup

Evidence Mapping → Photo coaching per charge

Defense Letter → Statutory citations, court-ready

Upload Landlord's Deduction Letter→ Check If Your Landlord Broke the Law

PDF or photo · free instant analysis · no credit card required

Bank-Level Security

Applicable Law

Stripe Secure

Upload Landlord's Deduction Letter

Upload the move-out statement or email from your landlord

Charge Extraction

HUD / IRS useful-life lookup

Evidence Mapping

Photo coaching per charge

Defense Letter

Statutory citations, court-ready

Regulatory Authority

Your Landlord's Charges Meet Federal Depreciation Law

Surfaces

Paint → 3 Years

HUD Handbook 4350.1 defines useful life. After 3 years, repainting is typically the landlord's cost.

HUD 4350.1

Textile

Carpet → 5 Years

HUD MAP Guide 5C. Normal traffic wear is expected, not tenant damage.

MAP 5C

Appliances

Appliances → 10–15 Years

IRS Publication 527. Charging for normal wear on aged appliances is generally not allowed.

IRS Pub 527

$847

Avg Recovery

89%

Success Rate

2.4k+

Disputes Filed

Recent Wins

"After 4 years in that apartment, they wanted $900 for carpet replacement. The carpet was ancient — completely past its lifespan. Landlord didn't even argue."

— Birmingham, AL

"When I moved out, the landlord wanted $600 for repainting after 4 years. Paint wears out after 3. Got my money back within a week."

— Phoenix, AZ

"After 6 years my landlord charged $800 for carpet. That carpet was ancient — way past any reasonable lifespan. Got every dollar back."

— Los Angeles, CA

Trusted by tenants nationwide

4.8/5